Email

Recent Court Decisions

Recent court and agency decisions involving board work

IASB's Office of General Counsel prepares summaries chosen from the Illinois Supreme and Appellate courts, federal court, agencies, the Illinois Public Access Counselor, and other tribunals issuing interesting decisions. Information in the summaries is limited to a brief synopsis and is not intended for purposes of legal advice. For the complete text of any case cited in this section, go to the Illinois state courts, Illinois Attorney General, or Federal courts finder links.

To search by the names of the plaintiff or defendant or other keyword, use the site search box located at the top of this website. Then filter results by Court Decision.

Questions regarding Recent Court and Agency Decisions should be directed to Maryam Brotine, ext. 1219, or by [email protected].


Court decisions are listed in order of the date posted, with the most recent shown first.

  • General Interest to School Officials
    Decision Allowing Request for Property Annexation into Different School District is Struck Down
    Case: Board of Education of Jasper County v. Regional Board of School Trustees, (Ill. App. Ct. 2026)
    Decision Date: Wednesday, September 23, 2026

    Homeowners of property located in Jasper County (Petitioners) filed a petition with the Regional Board of School Trustees requesting that their property be detached from Jasper County School District (District 1) and annexed to Dieterich Community School District in Effingham County (District 30) through a proposed chain of linked properties. Their property was located approximately 1.5 miles from the boundary of District 30. Neighbors of the Petitioners located between the Petitioners' property and the District 30 boundary joined the petition, asking that 10-foot-wide strips of their properties be included to create a chain of linked properties for the detachment/annexation petition. With the proposed chain of linked properties, the petition alleged that the territory to be detached and annexed would be "compact and contiguous" to District 30.


    District 1 argued against the petition arguing that the petition did not comply with section 7-4 of the School Code because the detachment, if granted, would result in territory that was not "compact and contiguous" as required by the Illinois Constitution and the School Code. After multiple hearings and reviews at the Regional Board level and the circuit court level, on appeal to the Illinois Appellate Court (Court), the Court reviewed at length the entire record and determined that the Regional Board erred in granting the petition. The Court focused on the petitioners’ failure to make the threshold argument of how the proposed detachment and annexation would result in "compact and contiguous" districts as required by Illinois case law and statutes as well as the Illinois Constitution. The Court held that the petition should not have been granted, and it reversed the Regional Board's order and the circuit court's decision upholding the Regional Board's order. 


    A copy of the decision can be found here.

  • General Interest to School Officials
    Ruling in Favor of a School District Upheld in a Wrongful Death Lawsuit
    Case: Falconer v. East St. Louis School District No. 189 (5th Dist.)
    Decision Date: Friday, September 18, 2026

    An Illinois Appellate Court in the 5th District upheld a circuit court that had ruled in favor of the East St. Louis School District No. 189 district (School District) finding that the School District had immunity under the Local Government and Governmental Employees Tort Immunity Act (Tort Immunity Act) in a wrongful death lawsuit brought by the mother of a student-athlete who had died. 


    The facts of the case are sensitive in nature. A student at the School District who was a football player collapsed in the school weight room. Two football coaches immediately came to help, called 911, and checked his vital signs. They found a pulse. Students ran to get medical assistants from the school’s health clinic who also found a pulse and took his blood pressure. The paramedics arrived and confirmed that the student had a detectable pulse and was breathing. Because he had a pulse and was breathing, no one administered the Automated External Defibrillator (AED) nor did they perform cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) while at the school. The student was transported to the hospital. At the hospital, he lost his pulse. CPR was administered there, but he died. An autopsy later revealed that he had a heart condition. 


    The School District was sued for wrongful death by the student’s mother who alleged negligence and willful and wanton conduct by the School District for failing to perform CPR and use the AED. In addition, the student’s mother argued that the School District failed to provide properly trained personnel and failed to have a statutorily mandated medical emergency plan to implement for the emergency that occurred in violation of the Illinois’s AED Act and Physical Fitness Facility Medical Emergency Preparedness Act. The circuit court found that the School District did have immunity under the Tort Immunity Act and that any specific statutory violations did not supersede the immunity provided by the Tort Immunity Act.


    Here, the Illinois Appellate Court upheld the ruling by the circuit court finding that the School District could not be liable because several sections of the Tort Immunity Act covered the district from liability, in particular noting immunity for discretionary acts of the employees. The court found the staff’s decision to render CPR or use an AED is purely discretionary in nature and is dependent on the necessity and propriety of the existing situational facts. The court rejected the applicability of the AED Act and the Facility Preparedness Act because the facts of the case did not trigger any requirement by the staff to use the AED or perform CPR. In all instances while at school the student was breathing and had a pulse, and therefore the court did not find that the AED Act and the Facility Preparedness Act superseded the applicable provisions of the Tort Immunity Act. The court further found that there was no causal connection between the staff’s actions at school and the student’s death at the hospital. Therefore, there was no finding of negligence nor willful or wanton conduct of the School District. 


    A copy of the decision can be found here.

  • Freedom of Information Act - FOIA
    Withholding Communications Exchanged with Third Party and Subsequently Sent to Attorney
    Case: Binding Opinion – 26-010
    Decision Date: Wednesday, August 26, 2026

    This binding opinion from the Illinois Attorney General’s Public Access Counselor (PAC) discusses an issue under the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) of whether the City of Chicago (City) Department of Law (Department) improperly withheld records responsive to a FOIA request seeking correspondence involving Mr. Robert Blackwell Jr.’s companies and the City. The records requested are messages and documents exchanged between Robert Blackwell, Jr., and the City's then-Chief Operating Officer, Paul Goodrich, involving City contracts. The Department's response to the PAC stated that those records were subsequently "received by an attorney for the City from a client-department as part of the client's seeking legal guidance” and therefore exempt from disclosure under FOIA.


    It is the public policy of the State of Illinois that "all persons are entitled to full and complete information regarding the affairs of government." 5 ILCS 140/1. Under FOIA, "(a]ll records in the custody or possession of a public body are presumed to be open to inspection or copying. Any public body that asserts that a record is exempt from disclosure has the burden of proving by clear and convincing evidence that it is exempt." 5 ILCS 140/1.2.


    Section 7(1)(m) of FOIA exempts from disclosure: “Communications between a public body and an attorney or auditor representing the public body that would not be subject to discovery in litigation, and materials prepared or compiled by or for a public body in anticipation of a criminal, civil or administrative proceeding upon the request of an attorney advising the public body, and materials prepared or compiled with respect to internal audits of public bodies. 


    A party asserting that a communication to an attorney is protected by the attorney-client privilege must show that: (1) a statement originated in confidence that it would not be disclosed; (2) it was made to an attorney acting in his legal capacity for the purpose of securing legal advice or services; and (3) it remained confidential." Cangelosi v. Capasso, 366 Ill. App. 3d 225, 228 (2006). A public body that withholds records under section 7(1)(m) "can meet its burden only by providing some objective indicia that the exemption is applicable under the circumstances." Illinois Education Ass'n v. Illinois State Board of Education, 204 Ill. 2d 456, 470 (2003). 


    In Johnson v. Frontier Ford, Inc., 68 Ill. App. 3d 315, 317 (1979), the Illinois Appellate Court addressed whether the attorney-client privilege protects pre-existing documents forwarded by a client to their attorney in connection with a request for legal advice. The Court reasoned such records are not protected unless the privilege otherwise applied before the attorney obtained them.


    Here, the PAC reviewed the records at issue and determined that the records requested were not exempt from disclosure pursuant to Section 7(1)(m) because the withheld records did not originate in confidence between parties engaged in an attorney-client relationship and were not exchanged for the purpose of securing or providing legal advice. The PAC further noted that, “sending an attorney communications exchanged by a City employee and a third-party contractor for the City does not transform those records into privileged attorney-client communications.” The PAC concluded that the Department did not sustain its burden of demonstrating that the records are exempt from disclosure pursuant to section 7(1)(m) of FOIA. The PAC determined that the Department improperly withheld the contested record and directed the Department to provide unredacted copies of the withheld records to the requester.

    A copy of the decision can be found here.

  • Open Meetings Act - OMA
    Public Body Violated OMA for Voting to Terminate Employment after Failing to Provide Sufficient Advance Notice on the Board’s Meeting Agenda
    Case: Binding Opinion – 26-005
    Decision Date: Friday, May 15, 2026

    A member of the public submitted a request for review to the Illinois Attorney General's Public Access Counselor's office (PAC) alleging that the Village of Okawville Board of Trustees (Board) violated the Open Meetings Act (OMA) section 2.02 of OMA (5 ILCS 120/) during a public meeting by terminating a police officer after failing to provide sufficient advance notice in the meeting agenda of the proposed termination action.  

    Section 2.02(c) of OMA requires that a meeting agenda "set forth the general subject matter of any resolution or ordinance that will be the subject of final action at the meeting." This provision requires public bodies to include in agendas sufficient detail to notify members of the public of the types of final actions that public bodies anticipate taking at their meetings. The term “general subject matter” is ambiguous according to the PAC. Through legislative history, the PAC noted that the General Assembly chose to change in 2013 from the phrase, which had only required that an action be “germane to a subject on the agenda,” to “general subject matter.” At a minimum, section 2.02(c) requires the Board's agenda to include the general category of employee and the general type of personnel transaction at issue. 

    Section 2(c)(1) of OMA permits closed session discussion regarding "[t]he appointment, employment, compensation, discipline, performance, or dismissal of specific employees of the public body[.]" However, the Board's public recital before entering closed session, which is required by section 2a of OMA, has no relevance to whether the Board's meeting agenda provided sufficient advance notice as separately required by section 2.02(c) of OMA.

    Here, the Board’s meeting agenda listed “Personnel Issues” under a heading for “Police & Liquor.” The agenda also contained a reference to holding a closed session to discuss “personnel” under the exception in section 2(c)(1) of OMA. There was no inclusion in the agenda of any advance notice that the Board would take action to terminate the employment of a police officer. The PAC surmised that a member of the public could only possibly discern from the combined information on the agenda that personnel issues about either a police or liquor employee or potential employee would be discussed by the Board during closed session regarding one of the employment actions under 2(c)(1).  

    The PAC found that the meeting agenda did not set forth the general subject matter of the Board's vote to terminate the employment of a police officer. The agenda item identified neither the employee category at issue nor the type of personnel transaction to be considered by the Board. The PAC determined that a member of the public who read the agenda before the meeting would not have generally known what the Board would be acting upon, and therefore, the Board failed to provide sufficient advance notice for the termination of a police officer's employment as required by section 2.02(c). 

    The PAC directed the Board to remedy this violation by re-voting on the termination of the employee after posting a meeting agenda that provides sufficient detail to identify the general subject of that final action. At a minimum, the PAC set the requirement that the Board should create a relevant agenda item that would identify the category of employee and the type of personnel action to be considered at the meeting. 

    A copy of the decision can be found here.

  • Open Meetings Act - OMA
    Public Body Violated OMA for Discussing Topics in Closed Session
    Case: Binding Opinion – 26-004
    Decision Date: Wednesday, May 13, 2026

    A member of the public submitted a request for review to the Illinois Attorney General's Public Access Counselor's office (PAC) alleging that the City of Lebanon (City) City Council (Council) violated the Open Meetings Act (OMA) section 2(a) of OMA (5 ILCS 120/) during two separate public meetings by discussing topics in closed session that are not authorized by any of the exceptions to the general requirement that public bodies conduct public business openly. 


    Section 2(a) of OMA requires that "[a]ll meetings of public bodies shall be open to the public unless excepted in subsection (c) and closed in accordance with Section 2a." Such exceptions “are in derogation of the requirement that public bodies meet in the open, and therefore, the exceptions are to be strictly construed, extending, only to subjects clearly within their scope.” 


    The City Council relied on section 2(c)(5) of OMA to close the December 22, 2025, and February 9, 2026, meetings in relation to setting prices for the sale or lease of property. The section 2(c)(5) exception applies to the “purchase or lease of real property for the use of the public body, including meetings held for the purpose of discussing whether a particular parcel should be acquired.”


    Here, the Council’s closed session discussions at the December 22, 2025, and February 9, 2026, meetings concerned the merits of properties that the City potentially could purchase. Closed session discussion of those properties was authorized under Section 2(c)(5) of OMA. However, the Council’s discussion of its future plans for the current City Hall building were not authorized for closed session under Section 2(c)(5).


    The PAC found that the Council violated OMA during its December 22, 2025, and February 9, 2026, meetings by improperly discussing the existing City Hall building in closed session. The PAC determined that the discussions of potential property purchases and future plans for current city buildings could have been separated from the discussion of the existing property.


    The PAC directed the Council to remedy the violation by disclosing its closed session verbatim recordings and closed session minutes from the December 22, 2025, and February 9, 2026, meetings concerning the current City Hall building to the requestor and the public. The PAC allowed the Council to redact the portions of the recordings and minutes concerning the potential acquisition of other properties, which is covered by the closed meeting exception under Section 2(c)(5).

     

    A copy of the decision can be found here.