Ruling in Favor of a School District Upheld in a Wrongful Death Lawsuit
An Illinois Appellate Court in the 5th District upheld a circuit court that had ruled in favor of the East St. Louis School District No. 189 district (School District) finding that the School District had immunity under the Local Government and Governmental Employees Tort Immunity Act (Tort Immunity Act) in a wrongful death lawsuit brought by the mother of a student-athlete who had died.
The facts of the case are sensitive in nature. A student at the School District who was a football player collapsed in the school weight room. Two football coaches immediately came to help, called 911, and checked his vital signs. They found a pulse. Students ran to get medical assistants from the school’s health clinic who also found a pulse and took his blood pressure. The paramedics arrived and confirmed that the student had a detectable pulse and was breathing. Because he had a pulse and was breathing, no one administered the Automated External Defibrillator (AED) nor did they perform cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) while at the school. The student was transported to the hospital. At the hospital, he lost his pulse. CPR was administered there, but he died. An autopsy later revealed that he had a heart condition.
The School District was sued for wrongful death by the student’s mother who alleged negligence and willful and wanton conduct by the School District for failing to perform CPR and use the AED. In addition, the student’s mother argued that the School District failed to provide properly trained personnel and failed to have a statutorily mandated medical emergency plan to implement for the emergency that occurred in violation of the Illinois’s AED Act and Physical Fitness Facility Medical Emergency Preparedness Act. The circuit court found that the School District did have immunity under the Tort Immunity Act and that any specific statutory violations did not supersede the immunity provided by the Tort Immunity Act.
Here, the Illinois Appellate Court upheld the ruling by the circuit court finding that the School District could not be liable because several sections of the Tort Immunity Act covered the district from liability, in particular noting immunity for discretionary acts of the employees. The court found the staff’s decision to render CPR or use an AED is purely discretionary in nature and is dependent on the necessity and propriety of the existing situational facts. The court rejected the applicability of the AED Act and the Facility Preparedness Act because the facts of the case did not trigger any requirement by the staff to use the AED or perform CPR. In all instances while at school the student was breathing and had a pulse, and therefore the court did not find that the AED Act and the Facility Preparedness Act superseded the applicable provisions of the Tort Immunity Act. The court further found that there was no causal connection between the staff’s actions at school and the student’s death at the hospital. Therefore, there was no finding of negligence nor willful or wanton conduct of the School District.
A copy of the decision can be found here.